Year: 2012

  • The news doesn’t wait, so more edits needed

    My poor publisher. I’ve had to make more changes to the text, which has already been typeset. This time, it’s because this week’s threatened libel suit against a prominent website meant I have to update the following paragraph on page 170. Changes in red, with some phrases deleted to keep the length unchanged:

    Thus, the internet has become a lively counter-hegemonic space, where contentious journalism challenges the status quo in a way not seen for decades. A government not known for its tolerance of opposition showed remarkable self-restraint in its reaction to online dissent — even in cases when the critics were fully within reach of the authorities. This was certainly not because it had become liberal in outlook. Defamation suits, prosecutions for contempt of court and other actions against offline expression continued to punctuate Singapore’s political calendar. In effect, the government operated a dual regulatory system for media, with stricter standards applied to print and broadcasting than to online media. The idea of differential censorship for mass media and niche media was not new: . In the pre-internet era, this principle was enshrined in the film classification system, which allowed films that would have to be censored for television broadcast to be screened uncut for adult audiences in cinemas. Similarly, books and plays were regulated less stringently than newspapers. In the early years of the web, the same logic might have applied to internet regulation: websites were niche media and did not require the same scrutiny as the national news media organisations. Quickly, though, some online media became mass media with tens of thousands of readers, as many as smaller newspapers such as the Business Times, Berita Harian or Tamil Murasu. In early 2012, government leaders threatened to sue Yawning Bread and TREmeritus (the new incarnation of Temasek Review) for libel, indicating its preparedness to act against prominent websites. However, wild anonymous attacks on the establishment continued unabated on various online forums and Facebook. The government appeared to reconcile itself to a new political terrain where it would no longer fully control what was said or shown publicly.

  • TREmeritus apologises to Lee Hsien Loong and promises not to repeat libel

    by

    CHERIAN GEORGE

    February 22nd, 2012

    TREmeritus has posted an apology to the Prime Minister, two days before the deadline his lawyers gave the site to avoid being sued for defamation. The formal apology – carried in the lead article in the site’s “Editorials and News” section with a prominent graphic of a yellow post-it note that says “Sorry!” – reads as follows:

    APOLOGY

    1. On or about 16 February 2012, we published on this website, TR Emeritus, an article entitled “PAP-government is full of ironies“ (the “Article”). The Article, and the comments in response to the Article, was available at http://www.tremeritus.com/2012/02/16/pap-government-is-full-­of-ironies/.
    2. We recognise that the Article meant or was understood to mean that Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong had secured, or was instrumental in securing, the appointment of his wife, Mdm Ho Ching, as the Chief Executive Officer of Temasek Holdings (Private) Limited for nepotistic motives.
    3. We admit and acknowledge that this allegation is false and completely without foundation. We unreservedly apologise to Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong for the distress and embarrassment caused to him by this allegation.
    4. We have removed the Article and the comments in response to the Article and undertake not to make any further allegation to the same or similar effect.

    Giving the background to the case, the article also quotes an extract from the lawyers’ letter of 19 February. It cites a passage from the offending 16 February article, which claimed that Koh Boon Hwee, for example, was more qualified than the PM’s wife Ho Ching to head Temasek Holdings. It said that this was just one of “10,001 examples” of cronyism in Singapore. The article, by a Matthew Chua, was taken down the same day as the lawyers’ letter was delivered to TRE’s Singapore-based editor Richard Wan.

    It is not known whether TRE acceded to the lawyers’ additional demand that the site reveal to them the identity of Matthew Chua.

    In TRE’s article today, the site noted the lawyers’ statement that Ho Ching had been appointed “on merit and through proper process”.

    “Additionally, Messer Drew & Napier was kind enough to provide TRE with information pertaining to the appointment of Mdm Ho Ching, which showed that Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong was not involved in the decision making process. As a matter of fact, Mr Lee was against the idea from the onset,” said the apology, which was signed by Wan on behalf of the website.

    “In light of the information made available to TRE, we would like to offer our sincere apology to Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong.”

    The article ends with an appeal to readers not to post libellous material, saying that such posts would be deleted. Comments for the article were closed – an unusual move for a site famed for colourful remarks from anonymous readers.

    Significance

    The apology marks something of a comedown for a site – previously known as Temasek Review – that once took obvious glee in publishing conspiracy theories and creative concoctions against the establishment. For example, in its earlier incarnation, it sparked the flaming of PAP newbie Tin Pei Ling with an article that showed pictures of her posing with a regular-looking guy, suggesting that this was a boyfriend whom she had cruelly dumped in order to pursue a relationship with the senior civil servant whom she eventually married.

    Last week, Wan appeared at a forum saying that TRE wanted a new responsible and pro-Singapore image. It was the first time that an editor had come out into the open. He said that this would make it easier for TRE to talk to sources with information that could corroborate the many tip-offs it received. However, this also meant that the authorities now had a flesh-and-blood target to pursue in any legal action, as Wan discovered the hard way on Sunday.

    TREmeritus claims a higher viewership rank than the mainstream site, Today Online, which is controlled by Temasek Holdings.

    At the talk last week, Wan said that the site would be happy to publish replies when officials felt the site had gotten something wrong. By invoking defamation law instead against the high-profile site, the government has drawn the ire of netizens. The Online Citizen, for example, has urged the government to rethink its use of defamation suits against what it sees as unfounded criticism.

    “A better way to respond to defamation in today’s world, is to directly rebut the claims,” it said in an editorial. “While this can be difficult if one is seeking to prove a negative, it is still much more effective than lawsuits and legal letters. Tell your own story, openly, frankly and candidly. An authentic and honest response will always ring true, and people will be able to tell your sincerity for what it is.”

    Groundbreaking?

    The PM’s action against TRE – and law minister K. Shanmugam’s against Yawning Bread – are being widely seen as a turning point in the government’s management of alternative online media. Apparently cowed by the tidal wave of online dissent that marked last year’s general election, the government has now signalled that it will not hesitate to use old-fashioned weapons against critics that cross Singapore’s legal limits, online as well as offline.

    However, this is not in fact the first time that defamation is being threatened against online media. Ten years ago, Muslim site Fateha.com and individual poster Robert Ho were investigated for criminal defamation. The editor of Fateha fled the country, while the case against Ho was dropped because he was found to be of unsound mind.

    Defamation appears in both civil and criminal law in Singapore. While the use of civil defamation suits in Singapore has been controversial, such laws exist everywhere. In contrast, treating defamation as a criminal matter is increasingly regarded internationally as too extreme a restriction on freedom of expression. Significantly, although book author Alan Shadrake was initially charged with criminal defamation, this was never pursued. Therefore, students of media law might see the latest action against TRE as another indication that criminal defamation has come to be regarded by the government as obsolete and internationally unacceptable, even though it remains in the books.

  • Hard landing: TREmeritus welcomed into the open with defamation threat

    by

    CHERIAN GEORGE

    February 20th, 2012

    TREMERITUS, BETTER KNOWN AS as the former Temasek Review, has been given until 24 February to comply with instructions from lawyers acting for the Prime Minister, failing which the site’s editors could be sued for defamation.

    The move represents a rude welcome to the open ground of Singapore’s mediascape. Until recently, TREmeritus and its predecessor sites operated underground, with anonymous editors presumably based overseas. In recent months, however, one Richard Wan has emerged as the Singapore face of the controversial and hard-hitting site. Last Wednesday, he spoke at a public forum on social media.

    One day later, TREmeritus published a commentary by a Matthew Chua, which among other things made claims about Ho Ching’s appointment as head of Temasek Holdings. In a sign of the editors’ lack of experience in such matters, the article ended with an editor’s note saying that the author had nothing to worry about as long as he stayed clear of sedition or racism. Somehow, TREmeritus forgot about defamation, which for some decades has been among the country’s most frequently used media laws (another being contempt of court).

    It was left to Drew & Napier, acting for PM Lee Hsien Loong, to remind Wan that a string of media had been successfully sued for defamation over similar allegations. Their letter yesterday demanded that the offending article be taken down and that an apology be carried prominently on the website, for a period as long as the article had remained on the site.

    Legal action will proceed if the site fails to do so. The editors must inform Lee’s lawyers of their decision no later than 23 February.

    Wan could consider himself lucky that the site is being given a chance to play ball before being asked to shell out damages and costs. In some previous cases involving foreign media organisations, they had to write out large cheques despite issuing retractions and apologies. The services of senior counsel Davinder Singh, acting for Lee, hardly come cheap.

    The PM and his advisors probably took into account the fact that Wan, a 49-year-old IT consultant, does not have pockets as deep as those of Bloomberg, The Economist, Financial Times, Dow Jones and other media corporations that have contributed heftily to Singaporean charities via damages paid to politicians here. Wan and his fellow editors are likely to take the warning shot seriously enough. In addition, bankrupting an individual Singaporean over defamation is likely to go down badly today in the court of public opinion.

    TREmeritus has already removed the offending article from its website. It remains to be seen whether it will eat humble pie and issue the required apology. If it does so, it will probably have to take extra care in removing similar allegations from future articles and comments, since it can no longer claim ignorance after this episode.

    Acceding to the lawyers’ demands would be a major climbdown for a site known for its no-holds-barred attacks on government. The site’s overseas-based and anonymous editors are an unknown quantity, so it is a mystery whether they will have enough sympathy for Wan’s plight to engage in a collective swallowing of pride.

    This is (at least) the third defamation case involving a prominent socio-political blog within the past year. Also last week, Yawning Bread had to delete comments mentioning law minister K Shanmugam’s personal life. Similar allegations were contained in a comment posted on The Online Citizen around the time of last year’s general election. The Online Citizen’s editors quietly removed the comment after hearing from lawyers.

    Collectively, these cases illustrate the dilemma faced by citizen journalists and commentators who want to critique the government more forcefully than the mainstream media does. The internet can be used either as a hiding place or as a connector. Each strategy has its pros and cons.

    Those who use the internet to stay clear of the authorities, like the old Temasek Review, tend to find it difficult to cultivate sources and allies – this was a key reason why TREmeritus decided to come out of the shadows, according to Wan. In contrast, the likes of Yawning Bread and The Online Citizen have strong connections with Singapore’s civil society. Operating openly and transparently tends to make sites more credible. However, working in the open also means that they are no longer immune to the same post-publication legal constraints that restrict mainstream journalists.

    Faced with this reality, it could be back to the drawing board for the individuals behind TREmeritus. It would not be surprising if some of them – and those associated with its predecessor site, Temasek Review – decide to heed the call of the wild and return to the less regulable regions of cyberspace.

  • Temasek Review’s offspring wants a more responsible image

    by

    CHERIAN GEORGE

    February 16th, 2012

    TREmeritus, the successor to Temasek Review, is taking tentative steps towards respectability, with an editor emerging from behind the website’s traditional curtain of anonymity to appear at a public forum this evening.

    Announcing himself the sole Singapore-based editor of TREmeritus, Richard Wan said that he and his colleagues felt it would be a good idea to “show a face to the public” and project themselves as “responsible” and “pro-Singapore”. “We are not terrorists,” he said.

    In previous incarnations, the site has been called Wayang Party, Temasek Review and Temasek Review Emeritus. It disappeared for several months soon after last May’s elections and resurfaced as TREmeritus (TRE) in December. Since then, the site’s ranking has climbed rapidly and has just hit 102, overtaking the mainstream Today Online, according to Wan.

    The IT professional and part-time blogger was speaking at a Social Media Week event at Sinema, together with The Online Citizen’s editor Ravi Philemon.

    He said that coming out into the open would make it easier for the site to get information from sources, including to verify the many anonymous tip-offs that the editors regularly receive.

    He also said that TRE welcomed engagement with the government. He revealed that minister of state Halimah Yaacob and an aide of minister Tan Chuan-Jin had written to the site to correct information carried there.

    While TRE was “99 percent” pro-opposition, this was necessary to balance the pro-PAP stand of mainstream media, he said. But he countered the perception that TRE was especially supportive of the Singapore Democratic Party. He said that the perception was due to the large number of SDP articles carried on the site. This, he said, was because the SDP and the Reform Party were the only two that accepted the site’s open invitation around the time of the last election to sign up for an account that would allow them a more direct method of contributing content.

    Furthermore, SDP had very good writers who produced a steady stream of articles. He joked that SDP should “slow down a bit” to avoid giving people the impression that TRE was partisan.

    Wan revealed that the site is grappling with the issue of how much to moderate comments. On the one hand, editors wanted comments to reflect ground sentiments. Furthermore, they did not have the resources to moderate all the discussions on the site. On the other hand, they recognised the need to edit racist and vulgar comments. Also, the site wanted to promote intelligent discussion. “After a while, it’s quite tiring to have all these nonsense comments,” said Wan.

    He said that TREmeritus would continue to give space to hard-hitting articles, including those that would not pass The Online Citizen’s “more stringent” editing. He and Philemon revealed that on one occasion, the TOC editor had passed TRE an “unverifiable rumour” that TOC could not publish. They stressed that there was no formal coordination between their sites, but that the old enmity that existed between TOC and TRE’s previous incarnations was over.

    The question-and-answer session brought out a candid admission that a more responsible TRE is still a work in progress. A member of the audience questioned Wan about a posting today on former Workers’ Party MP Yaw Shin Leong’s troubles. In addition to repeating the widely circulated rumour about an affair with another married WP member, TRE referred to liaisons with five other women.

    Poring over an iPad handed to him from the audience, Wan professed surprise and said that the version he had written and posted just before the forum included no such mention of additional dalliances. This must have been added later by one of the overseas editors, he said, adding that he would fix it later. “This is why, every day, I only sleep five or six hours. I don’t know how long I can last,” he said, to laughter.

  • The trust deficit

    Freedom From The Press shows how the Singapore government has tried to insulate itself from press scrutiny in order to give the executive maximum room for manoeuvre. In the final chapter, I suggest that are limits to this model. It occurs to me that one major limitation is that a system that’s closed to competition is likely to viewed as untrustworthy, in an age when people value accountability and transparency. This is an idea I explored in a speech at the Institute of Policy Studies’ Singapore Perspectives 2012 conference on 16 January 2012. Here is an article based on the speech, which appeared in The Straits Times on 19 January 2012.

    Government needs to build up public trust

    Since last year’s General Election, the government has been intent on improving its communication with the public. Officials believe they must make their presence felt on Facebook and other social media platforms. And they show no sign of loosening their grip on mainstream media as a vehicle for reaching out to the public.* Through traditional and new media, the government will intensify its efforts to explain its policies.

    On its own, though, such engagement will probably fail to improve the PAP’s prospects. After all, it is not as if the government used to be reticent. Consider the most controversial issues of the GE: immigration, social safety nets, public transport, housing prices and ministerial salaries. On every one of these issues, the government’s position was articulated, loud and clear, before and during the GE.

    It strains credibility to say that if only government leaders had used Facebook and other social media earlier and more enthusiastically, voters would have been more receptive to these policies. Similarly, it defies logic to suggest that if establishment media had repeated government positions with even greater fidelity than they did, the gap between government and people would have been narrowed.

    Increased communicativeness will be more persuasive only if the context – the communication environment – changes. The element in the communication environment that is critically lacking is trust.

    There are at least three barriers to building the required trust. First, the primary platform through which government communicates with the public, the mainstream media, suffers from a credibility problem.

    In most areas of coverage, the media are professional enough to provide a valued and reliable service. However, on the most controversial issues of the day, the government’s media policy dictates that the professional judgment of editors must be subordinate to elected officials’ judgments. The press is expected to educate the public and rally the nation behind the government, rather than push the government to respond to the people.

    On all the election hot-button issues, mainstream media did reflect public disenchantment, but always in soft focus. Thus, people never got the impression that the media were on their side.

    Second, the communication environment lacks independent voices in public debates – state and non-state institutions that stand apart from the executive, with the competence and credibility to comment authoritatively on problems and policies. These could include ombudsmen, independent commissions, think-tanks and other non-partisan expert institutions.

    PAP philosophy has not been enamoured of such intra-elite checks and balances because of the fear that these would slow down governance and confuse the public. But these risks are small relative to the benefits, in the form of the increased trust that could accrue to the government when more of its decisions are subject to independent scrutiny by competent institutions.

    Finally, trust is eroded by conflicts of interest, between national interest and party interest. While there is significant overlap between the two, the interests of the ruling party and those of Singapore are not exactly the same.

    The most salient example is the way electoral boundaries are drawn. The process is, beyond reasonable doubt, managed to benefit the PAP. Similarly, unequal treatment towards opposition constituencies when rolling out government programmes and services simply does not pass the smell test.

    The number of such cases may be few, but the odour of partisanship hangs in the air and sticks to other unpopular policies, even those that an objective analysis might conclude are justified as being in the national interest. Cynicism will continue to corrode trust as long as there are specific areas in which the government has, in the eyes of any reasonable Singaporean, put party before nation.

    Building trust in the communication environment is critically important because citizens can only take so much information about policies before their eyes glaze over. Some will demand detailed facts and figures. If the government is on firm ground, it should have no compunctions about providing the data. For most citizens, however, it will be about taking a leap of faith, and that is where trust gives you wings.

    The PAP used to pride itself in the trust that it was able to command. But the way Singaporeans trust has changed, and not just in politics.

    In an earlier era, we had faith in doctors because of the aura they projected. Today, if we trust our doctors, it is not because we think they are gods, nor because we have studied medicine ourselves and can personally check on their every move. Our trust is based on the assurance that our doctors function within a regulatory system that compels them to act in our interest, that the penalties for those who fail to do so are very high, and that we can get a second opinion whenever we are doubtful.

    Such commonsense principles apply to the political sphere as well. It is neither policymakers’ high status nor repetition of their diagnoses and prescriptions that will persuade the public to swallow bitter medicine, but the assurance that they will open their decisions to independent scrutiny and verification.

    In his remarks at Monday’s Institute of Policy Studies conference, Deputy Prime Minister Tharman Shanmugaratnam credited the Singapore public with enough collective intelligence to make astute decisions in the country’s interest. As part of that sea change, accountability is prized far higher than traditional notions of authority.

    Since Singaporeans no longer expect their leaders to be demigods, evidence of fallibility is not a liability. On the contrary, timely and unvarnished revelations of government’s mistakes are the proof people need that they are operating in a trustworthy communication environment. Conversely, if institutions are only capable of reporting that the government is right, it should not be surprising when official communication is not believed.

     

    * This sentence was deleted by ST editors and does not appear in the published version. It is not a major loss and I agreed to the change (my submission was too long, so something had to give). I highlight the redaction here because it illustrates how the Singapore press does not like to say too much about the controls it faces. This distinguishes the media here from the media in most authoritarian states, where journalists try their best to reveal the conditions under which they work. What accounts for the Singapore media’s stoic silence? This is a question I try to answer in my book chapter, “Freedom of the Press: A Cause without Rebels”. (Yes, this is another shameless plug.)

  • Public policy, public opinion and the trust deficit

    by

    CHERIAN GEORGE

    January 17th, 2012

    Edited extract of a presentation at the Institute of Policy Studies’ Singapore Perspectives 2012 conference, 16 January 2012.

    The government is convinced that making its presence felt in social media will reap dividends. On their own, though, such efforts will probably fail. The element in the communication environment that is critically lacking, without which any additional communicativeness would be futile, is trust. That trust cannot grow if the media are forced to side with public policy against public opinion 100% of the time, if we lack independent institutions to scrutinise the work of the executive, and if the government continues to conflate party interests with national interests.

    Many of today’s speakers have addressed the possibility that changes in policy will help to heal the current rift between government and people. Even after better policies are formulated, however, a challenge remains –how to win over a skeptical, even cynical, public.

    Given the government’s great anxiety since last year’s election that online anarchy could lead public opinion astray, it is timely to look at this issue here and now. But this is a problem that pre-dates Facebook and Twitter. It goes to the heart of one of democratic theory’s greatest dilemmas. Democracies face the risk that individual choices won’t add up to collective well-being. Individuals can fail to act in their own long-term interests, or fail to consider the interests of their fellow citizens.

    As a result, there will always be gaps between public opinion and even the soundest public policy. Democratic systems manage this problem by improving the flow of information to and among citizens, as well as by insulating certain spheres of decision-making from democratic choice, on the grounds that these are better left to experts – the rule of law, for example, requires that the judicial system is shielded from the vagaries of public opinion.

    Information vs insulation

    The favoured balance between information and insulation differs from society to society. Singapore’s resolution of this dilemma is the result of two apparently contradictory convictions. On the one hand is its belief in being forthright with the people – often in exhaustive, repetitive detail. In contrast to the fantasies that are routinely peddled by leaders in many other countries, the PAP has a tradition of being brutally honest about Singapore’s challenges, limitations and vulnerabilities. Our National Day Rallies, for example, are unusually sombre and didactic events in the world of political speechmaking.

    This communicative compulsion is counter-balanced, though, by a deep-seated pessimism about the public’s potential to rise to the challenge of democratic citizenship. In common with theorists of democratic elitism such as Walter Lippmann, the PAP believes that democracy needs to be protected from itself – that beyond a point, public participation is destabilising.

    Lippmann wrote that enlightened public opinion was an unworkable fiction and unattainable ideal, like asking a fat man to be a ballet dancer. He favoured government guided by experts. Similarly, the PAP believes it would be naïve and perilous to hold high hopes in ordinary people’s capacity to absorb the knowledge and temperament required of active citizens in a participatory democracy. In some areas, decisions are seen as simply too technical; in others, the gulf between short-term individual interests and long-term societal interests too cavernous; while some issues are viewed as too visceral to expect people to exercise cool rationality.

    The PAP’s low expectations of the public are seen in Singapore’s broadcasting policies. When the government progressively loosened the leash around the neck of the national broadcaster in the 1980s, the stations were not asked to emulate the BBC-style independent public service model. Instead, in line with the market fetishism of the times, policy-makers decided that TV was inevitably about show business.

    This is significant because international research has shown that the level of basic political knowledge in a society – the kind of awareness that we expect citizens to have – is closely related to the strength of public service broadcasting. Current debates in Singapore are obsessed about the internet, but we have probably not looked hard enough at the three decades of television policy, which may have been the single most powerful cultural factor behind cultivating an entire generation of Singaporeans as consumers of public services instead of citizens with a right and responsibilities to participate in public life.

    The Singapore strategy thus far has been to develop a public opinion that can be trusted to follow wise leadership, but not attempt to take the lead.

    Communicativeness is not enough

    Over the decades, nonetheless, PAP leaders have acknowledged that they must meet the growing demands for information and explanation from a better-educated and more skeptical population. Last year’s GE has pushed this trend further. The government is now convinced that making its presence felt in social media will reap dividends.

    On their own, though, such efforts will probably fail to achieve the desired result.

    Consider the most controversial issues of GE2011: immigration, social safety nets, public transport, housing prices, ministerial salaries. On all these issues, people had ample opportunity to hear the government’s arguments before and during the GE. Are we really to believe that if only politicians had used Facebook and other social media earlier and more enthusiastically, communication would have improved and the vote would have kinder to the PAP? I am incredulous. Similarly, I find it hard to accept that, if only Singapore’s establishment media had conveyed government positions with even greater fidelity than they did, the gap between government and people would have been narrowed.

    Increased communicativeness will be more persuasive only if the context – the communication environment – changes. The element in the communication environment that is critically lacking, without which any additional communicativeness would be futile, is trust.

    Barriers to trust

    In the past, the PAP counted mainly on its track record and charismatic leadership to engender that trust. This is no longer possible. And there are at least three current barriers to building trust.

    First, the primary platform through which government communicates with the public, the mainstream media, suffers from a credibility problem. In most areas of coverage, the media are professional enough to provide a valued and reliable service, including on most routine government news. However, at any one time, there are issues on which media credibility is low. The number of such issues may be small, but they are precisely the ones with the largest potential gap between policy and public opinion.

    In such cases, government media policy dictates that the independent professional judgment of editors must be subordinate to elected officials’ judgments. The press is expected to educate the public and rally the nation behind the government, rather than push the government to respond to the people. What this effectively means is that the media are required to manage, muffle and mute public discontent while affirming and amplifying the government view. On all the election hot-button issues, public discontent was never totally covered up by the media, but people never got the sense that the media were on their side. And this severely limits the power of the media to guide the public precisely where that influence is most needed.

    Second, the communication environment lacks independent voices in public debates: state and non-state institutions that stand apart from the executive, with the competence and credibility to comment authoritatively on problems and policies. These could include Ombudsmen, Commissions, independent think-tanks and other non-partisan expert institutions. This is where the PAP differs from theorists like Lippmann. Democratic elitism places its faith in a plural and competitive elite. PAP philosophy has not been enamoured of such intra-elite checks and balances because of the fear that these will slow down governance and confuse the public.

    These risks are small relative to the benefits, in the form of the increased trust that could accrue to the government when more of its decisions are subject to independent scrutiny by competent institutions. Singaporeans have come to expect such oversight in all areas of life where we ourselves cannot hope to muster the necessary expertise.

    Finally, there is the problem of conflict of interest, between national interest and party interest. While there is significant overlap between the interests of the ruling party and the interests of Singapore, these interests are not coterminous and most Singaporeans can see that. The most obvious example is the way electoral boundaries are drawn: the process is, beyond reasonable doubt, managed to benefit the PAP. Similarly, unequal treatment towards opposition constituencies when rolling out government programmes and services simply does not pass the smell test.

    The odour of partisanship hangs in the air and sticks to other unpopular policies, even those that an objective analysis might conclude are justified as being in the national interest. Cynicism will continue to corrode trust as long as there are specific areas in which the government has, in the eyes of any reasonable Singaporean, put party before nation.

    Accountability and transparency

    Building trust in the communication environment is critically important because, like it or not, theories of democratic elitism have a point. Citizens – even highly educated ones with an interest in public affairs – can only take so much information about policies before their eyes glaze over.  Some will demand facts and figures in great detail and if the government is on firm ground, it should have no compunctions about providing the data. For most, however, it will be about taking a leap of faith, and that is where trust gives you wings.

    That trust cannot grow if the media are consistently forced to side with policy against public opinion 100% of the time, if we lack independent institutions to scrutinise the work of the executive, and if the government continues to conflate party interests with national interests.

    In an earlier era, we had faith in doctors because of the aura that the medical profession projected. Today, if we trust our doctors, it is not because we think they are gods, nor because we have studied medicine ourselves and can check their every move, but because of the assurance that our doctors function within a regulatory system that compels them to act in our interest, that the penalties if they fail to do so are high, and that we can get a second opinion if we want.

    Such principles should be applicable to government as well. It is not mere repetition of our leaders’ diagnoses and prescriptions that will persuade the public to swallow bitter medicine, but the assurance that policy makers will open their decisions to independent scrutiny and verification.

    Since we no longer expect to led by gods, proof of fallibility is not a liability. On the contrary, timely revelations of government’s mistakes is the proof we need that we are operating in a trustworthy communication environment. Conversely, if our institutions are only capable of telling us that the government is right, it should not be surprising that they are not believed.

    Think tanks are supposed to think the unthinkable, and it is in this spirit that I have offered these comments. My prescription amounts to instituting limits on government and party – and the PAP has always operated on the principle of unlimited government in a dominant-party system. These ideas might be thinkable if the ship of state was in the dock, ready for an overhaul. But one of the ironies of Singapore’s success story is that because the ship is still cruising, it is that much harder to repair it. Asking the PAP to countenance a more open and competitive politics may be, to borrow Lippmann’s metaphor, like asking a fat man to be a ballet dancer. Whether it is unthinkable for a fat man to lose his extra pounds without losing himself is a question I will leave you with.